Only one player has worn the number in an AFL game. It is the highest number ever worn by a MFC player, except for a one-off 67 appearance in 2017.
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Andrew Dale | 1986 | |
Players who didn't play a senior match
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Bruce Joycey | 1981 | |
| David Muir | 1982 | #53 in 1981 |
| Rod Grinter | 1984 | #14 from 1985-1994 |
| Glen Kiley | 1985 | #52 and #55 in 1986 and #54 in 1987 |
| Brad Sparks | 1985 | #42 from 1987 to 1988 |
| Paul Smit | 1986 | |
| Dugald Aitken | 1987 | |
| Danny Lamb | 1987 | |
| Denis Knight | 1988 | |
| David Putamorsi | 1989 | |
| Tom Grehan | 1989 | |
| Anthony Lance | 1989 | |
| David Schwarz | 1989 | #44 in 1991, #5 from 1992-2002 |
| Brian Stynes | 1989-1990 | #49 in 1992 |
| Michael Hobbes | 1990 | |
| Leigh Capsalis | 1990 | |
| Danny McCarthy | 1990 | |
| Robert Lemon | 1990 | |
| Haydn Robins | 1990 | #46 in 1992, #15 in 1993 |
| Phillip Goldberg | 1991 | |
| Scott Nelson | 1991 | |
| Troy Shannon | 1991 | |
| Stephen Smith | 1992 | |
| Anthony Hardie | 1997 | |