Most games: 175 - Barry Bourke
Most goals: 154 - Barry Bourke
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Jack Bristow | 1912 | #18 in 1913 |
| Alf George | 1913 | #3 in 1912, 29 in 1915 |
| Mick Maguire | 1914 | #30 from 1912 to 1913 |
| Alec Gray | 1915-1921 | #22 in 1914 |
| Jimmy Abernethy | 1923-1924 | #4 from 1926 to 1932 |
| Ivor Warne-Smith | 1925-1932 | #33 in 1919 |
| Jack Richardson | 1932 | |
| Ray Usher | 1933 | #34 from 1928 to 1932 |
| Maurie Gibb | 1934-1937 | #10 from 1937 to 1943 |
| Jack Maher | 1938-1940 | #37 in 1944 |
| George Archibald | 1941-1945 | |
| Ron Hall | 1945-1947 | |
| Jack Furniss | 1947 | #26 from 1936 to 1940 |
| Eric Roscoe | 1948-1949 | |
| Robert Johnson | 1950-1952 | |
| Trevor Johnson | 1955-1962 | |
| Barry Bourke | 1963-73 | |
| Neil Chamberlain | 1974-1976 | #54 in 1973 |
| Chris Aitken | 1977 | #5 from 1967 to 1969 |
| Michael Byrne | 1977-1982 | |
| Roger Ellingworth | 1983-1984 | #34 from 1981 to 1982 |
| Rod Grinter | 1985-1994 | |
| Michael Polley | 1996 | |
| Leigh Newton | 1997 | |
| Steven Pitt | 2000-2001 | |
| Lynden Dunn | 2006-2016 | |
| Michael Hibberd | 2017- | |
Players who didn't play a senior match
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Les White | 1922 | |
| Luke Molan | 2002-2004 |