West Coast win by 22 points
The Demons looked good early, but when the West Coast midfield took over they were able to do enough to register a victory.
Despite the dominance of the Eagles in the centre, Melbourne were within a point at the last change.
A lack of forward targets, other than the dangerous Robertson, hurt Melbourne who saw their five match winning streak halted.
Brad Miller was suspended for two matches for striking.
"Judd injury sours West Coast AFL win" - The Age 28/05/2006