Melbourne win by 13 points
First game and first goal
The signs looked good for the Demons when rover Henry Coles kicked four goals in the first nine minutes, helping his side to a lead of over five goals at quarter time. Coles dominated around the packs and was ably assisted by Greg Wells and Barry Norsworthy in the middle. Robert Flower marshalled the wing and the Cats were behind by 35 points.
Shane Grambeau destroyed dangerous forward Larry Donohue, and Cat ruckman Ken Newland was busy torching chance after chance on his way to five behinds.
The Demons dominated all day and built up a 57 point lead early in the last quarter. It looked like a percentage boosting massacre was on the cards, but inexplicably the Cats racked up 44 points to nil in the next 13 minutes and the biggest comeback in history was a chance.
As the Cats charged back into the game in the last quarter coach Denis Jones abandoned the box and coached from the boundary line. He lamented the lack of experience in his side, saying "if we had lost the game I would have cut their throats", but he saved his best for the umpires with whom he was furious with for their interpretations of tackling rules. "I am going to keep talking about them - bugger them" he said.
Flower, Wells and Coles were best. Ray Biffin had been replaced in the selected squad by Robert Walters after suffering a knee injury. Smith strained his hamstring and was replaced by Thorne at half time.
Melbourne won $5000 from a sponsor who'd put the money up as a 'winner takes all' prize for the game.
Geelong 27.17.179 d. Melbourne 5.13.43
Goals - Cooke 3, Barrett 1, Graham 1
Best - Tippett, Woodman, Giulieri
Geelong 16.22.118 d. Melbourne 14.15.99
Goals - Angelis 3, Elshaug 2, Hayes 2, Quine 2, Saduaskas 2, Clarke 1, Love 1, Whitford 1
Best - Elshaug, Hayes, Merton