The following players have worn jersey number 12 in a VFL/AFL premiership match.
Most games: 233 - Todd Viney
Most goals: 358 - Jack Mueller
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Mal Kennedy | 1912 | |
| Jim Fitzpatrick | 1913 | #4 in 1912 |
| Bill Hendrie | 1915 | #5 in 1912, #11 in 1913, #15 in 1914 |
| Allan McLean | 1919 | |
| Bob Corbett | 1920-1921 | |
| Jack Power | 1930-1931 | #31 from 1932 to 1933 |
| Ted Thomas | 1932 | #3 from 1921 to 1928 |
| Alan Ryan | 1932-1933 | |
| Jack Mueller | 1934-1949 | #36 in 1950 |
| Stuart Spencer | 1950-1956 | |
| Neil Crompton | 1957 -1960 | #5 from 1962 to 1966 |
| Mike Collins | 1961-1962 | |
| Hugh Bromell | 1965 | |
| Chris Fowler | 1967-1969 | |
| Rod Payne | 1970 | |
| Mike Collins | 1972-1974 | #48 in 1971 |
| Marty Lyons | 1975-1977 | |
| Barry Norsworthy | 1977-1979 | |
| Cameron Clayton | 1979-1982 | |
| David Williams | 1983-1986 | |
| Todd Viney | 1987-1999 | |
| Colin Sylvia | 2004-2013 | |
| Dom Tyson | 2014-2018 | |
| Toby Bedford | 2020-2022 | |
| Lachie Hunter | 2023- | |
Players who didn't play a senior game
| Player | Years | Notes |
| David Hone | 1971 | #21 in 1969 |
| Nicholas Walsh | 2002-2003 |