Carnival era
| Years | Player |
| 1956, 1958, 1961 (c) | Ron Barassi |
| 1961 | Brian Dixon |
| 1966 | Hassa Mann |
| 1972 | Gary Hardeman |
| 1980, 1983 | Robert Flower |
| 1988 | Danny Hughes |
Selection committee era
| Years | Player |
| 1991, 1993 | Jim Stynes |
| 1993, 1994, 1995 | Garry Lyon |
| 1994 | Neale Balme (Coach) |
| 1994 | Stephen Tingay |
| 1995, 2002 | David Neitz |
| 1998 | Todd Viney |
| 2000 | Jeff Farmer |
| 2002 | Adem Yze |
| 2004 | Jeff White |
| 2006 | James McDonald |
| 2010 | James Frawley |
| 2010 | Mark Jamar |
| 2016, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022 | Max Gawn |
| 2017 | Michael Hibberd |
| 2018, 2021, 2022 | Clayton Oliver |
| 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023 | Christian Petracca |
| 2021 | Jake Lever |
| 2021 | Simon Goodwin (coach) |
| 2021, 2022 | Steven May |
AFLW
| Years | Player |
| 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021 | Paxy Paxman |
| 2017, 2018 | Elise O'Dea |
| 2017, 2018, 2022 (Summer) | Daisy Pearce |
| 2017 | Mel Hickey |
| 2018 | Meg Downie |
| 2019, 2022 (Summer) | Lauren Pearce |
| 2020, 2022 (Summer) | Libby Birch |
| 2020, 2022 (Spring) | Kate Hore |
| 2022 (Summer) | Tayla Harris |
| 2022 (Spring) | Olivia Purcell |