At an AGM held on Friday 17 April, it was revealed the club had debts of 17s 6d. Henry Harrison, Freeman and Byrne were elected the match committee and it was decided that from then on the club's uniform would be a scarlet cap.
After a slump that had lasted several years Melbourne's ranks were boosted by the permanent addition of Carlton players James Byrne, Charles Forrester and Harry Chadwick who had walked out on their club after an internal dispute. They went through the season without suffering a defeat.
Scratch matches commenced on Saturday 18 April, and a game was scheduled against Emerald Hill for 9 May. It was postponed for a fortnight. Another game against the club was set for 22 August but called off when the visitors could only muster nine players. Melbourne resolved not to play any games against Emerald Hill until they could prove themselves able to fulfil the fixture.
|16 May||South Yarra||DRAW|
|23 May||Emerald Hill||WIN|
|13 June||14th Regiment||WIN|
|11 July||14th Regiment||WIN|
|25 July||Emerald Hill||DRAW|
|1 August||South Yarra||WIN|
|29 August||South Yarra||WIN|
|5 September||14th Regiment||DRAW|
Dave Adamson, Charles Barrass, Wilton Barfoot, Barnes, Larry Bell, John Bennie, F. Bruford, James Byrne, Donald Campbell, H. Carr, Harry Chadwick, C. Chessell, JA Clarke, John Colville, Copeland, E. Disher, W. Finlay, Fitzgerald, Charles Forrester, J. Forrester, William Freeman, Ben Goldsmith, James Green, E. Harrison, Henry Harrison, Hor. Harrison, Tom Hepburn, Charlie Hillsden, E. Hinton, Tom Hope, E. Hurst, G. Hurst, W. Hurst, Richard Ireland, Tom Ireland, W. Johnston, W. King, T. Leach, F. Marsden, C. McCracken, McLennan, J. Moodie, S. Moodie, T. Moodie, D. Ogilvy, William Riggall, A. Robinson, Roche, James Stodart, J. Sullivan, W. Thomas, Williams
A C. Carr is shown as kicking a goal while H. Carr is shown as a player.
Another game against Emerald Hill on Saturday 20 June appears to not have been played. The 5 September game was listed in that day's papers as being against Carlton but ended up being played against 14th Regiment.
The next year the club claimed to have played in seven wins and six draws, meaning they considered one of the draws listed above to be a win.
Argus - 18/04/1868
Herald - 18/04/1868
Australasian - 25/04/1868
Argus - 02/05/1868
Argus - 25/08/1868
Argus - 27/08/1868
Age - 31/08/1868
"Origins of Australian Football: Volume 1" by Mark Pennings
Blueseum 1868 page